Regarding the Puig vs. Reddick playing time: I think it's probably best the way it is, right now. Puig gets way too overanxious in crunch time, his instincts are, let's say, suspect, and he's proven that in pretty much every playoff series he's been in, with the exception of the 2013 NLDS. His defense is, of course, great, and he does hit LHP, so he should have some form of consistent at-bats, but I just don't trust giving him a starting position, at least at this time. Don't get me started on his attempted bunt with two outs and a runner on third in game 2... vintage Puig.
Reddick isn't exactly wowing, either, and his defense is also, let's say, suspect, but he has been hitting since September. Probably not for a high SLG%, but he's definitely the better hitter, right now.